Is being sure getting in your way?

November 12th, 2026

I was thinking recently about how often I say things I’m completely sure of and how rarely I stop to check. If you listen in on almost any meeting or conversation you have you’ll hear them, things like:

That timeline won’t work.

We tried that two years ago.

She’s not ready for that role.

Obviously the client wants the cheaper option.

These are verdicts. A verdict is a decision already made. It sounds confident, it sounds efficient, and it quietly ends the conversation. A question, on the other hand, opens it up.

Certainty and curiosity

Certainty is the feeling that I already know, so there’s nothing left to find out.

For experienced women, certainty can feel a lot like competence. We’ve been rewarded for having the answers, so when something comes up in a meeting, the pull is to give the verdict, quickly and clearly, because surely that’s what we’re there for ('surely' is another verdict word LOL).

Curiosity is different. Curiosity is choosing to look for what I don’t yet know, rather than defend what I already think. It’s a mindset, a skill and a behaviour, which means it can be practised.

I've talked about certainty and knowing the answers in my second book 'Connecting Us'. Julie, is a client who had moved from an IT technical role, where she was the expert with all the answers, into a business role. And what she found was that her new business leaders didn’t understand her, and she didn’t understand them. When I suggested she ask them open questions, even when she thought she already knew the answer, she was puzzled because wasn’t she supposed to have the answers?

To her credit, she tried it anyway, and several weeks later she came back and said, “Is it really that easy?” It turns out that these business leaders' ideas were adding to her thinking and changed how she responded, so her working relationships became deeper than before.

Julie didn’t need to become more confident or know more. She needed to let go, just a little, of being sure.

One small move: Notice, Pause, Ask

  1. Notice. Certainty usually shows up in the body before we hear it in our words. A tight jaw. Hands in fists. Speaking a bit faster. Or a little word like “obviously” slipping out. These are your certainty signals. Just notice them.

  2. Pause. Take one breath before you respond. That breath gives you enough space to choose your words rather than default to the verdict.

  3. Ask. Turn the verdict into a genuine question, one you don’t already know the answer to. If you’re stuck, two good fallbacks are “What am I not seeing?” and “Whose view is missing here?”

This works whether the verdict is yours or someone else’s.

From verdict to question

Instead of: “That timeline won’t work.”

Try: “What would need to be true for that timeline to work?”

Instead of: “We tried that two years ago.”

Try: “What’s changed since then?”

Instead of: “She’s not ready for that role.”

Try: “What would ready look like, and who decided that?”

Instead of: “Obviously the client wants the cheaper option.”

Try: “What do we actually know about what matters most to them?”

You might still end up where you started. Perhaps the timeline really won’t work. But now you know why, and so does everyone else in the room.

This week’s experiment

Pick one meeting this week. The first time you feel a certainty signal, pause and ask one genuine question instead of giving the verdict. Then notice what happens to the conversation.

You may not need more answers. You may simply need a better question, and a door you didn’t realise was closed might open.

Maree

Subscribe to my newsletter
Be The Exceptional Leader in Your Field. Unlock you team magic.