I talk about beliefs a lot. In my newsletters, my programs, pretty much every coaching conversation. And it occurred to me recently that I've never stopped to explain what I actually mean.
So let's go back to the start.
What is a belief?
A belief is something we hold to be true about ourselves, other people or the world. Not a fact. An assumption that feels like a fact.
"I'm not a numbers person." "People like me don't get those roles." "If you want something done properly, do it yourself." "Hard work always pays off."
Most of the time we don't notice our beliefs at all. They sit quietly in the background, shaping what we see, what we try and what we don't. Which is why I often say: we don't believe what we see. We see what we already believe.
That's also why two people can walk out of the same meeting with completely different stories about what just happened. Same meeting. Different beliefs.
Where do beliefs come from?
Beliefs grow from what we see, hear, experience, read and think about. And a great many of them grow from what we soaked up as children, long before we had any say in the matter.
Think about the messages you picked up from your parents, your brothers and sisters, your teachers, your grandparents, the culture you grew up in:
"Money doesn't grow on trees." "Don't make a fuss." "You're the sensible one." "Good girls don't show off."
As children, we don't stop to question these. We take them in as how the world works. And because they've been with us so long, we rarely question them as adults either.
Some of these beliefs were genuinely useful at the time. "Don't talk to strangers" kept many of us safe as kids. But as a grown woman building a career, a network and a life, talking to people you don't know is pretty much the job. A belief that protected us at seven can quietly hold us back at forty-seven.
How a belief gets built: the Ladder of Inference
One of my favourite ways to explain how beliefs form is the Ladder of Inference, a model created by organisational psychologist Chris Argyris. It shows how we get from something that happens to a belief, often in a matter of seconds and without noticing.
Imagine a ladder. At the bottom of the ladder is everything that's actually going on around us, millions of bits of data: far more than any brain can take in. We have a process to manage all of that data which occurs as we climb up the ladder:
We select a few bits of what happened (without realising we're choosing).
We add meaning to those bits, based on our past experience.
We make assumptions about what that meaning says.
We draw conclusions.
We build a belief, or strengthen one we already have.
We act on that belief.
And here's the sneaky part. Once the belief is in place, it goes back down the ladder and influences what we select next time. So we keep noticing the evidence that fits, and filter out the rest.
Here's an example. I'm chairing a meeting and Mary arrives fifteen minutes late. I select that she's late. I add meaning: she was late the last time I chaired this meeting, too. I assume she doesn't respect me and is trying to disrupt things. I conclude there's no saving this relationship. And I build a belief: Mary doesn't support me. From then on, guess what I notice about Mary?
Now imagine I catch Mary after the meeting and simply ask about it. And she says every fourth Monday she takes her dad to an appointment, which makes her half an hour late. It just happens to line up with the meetings I chair.
Belief busted or at least amended.
Notice what happened. The facts didn’t change. The meaning I added did all the work.
Empowering and limiting beliefs
Broadly, beliefs fall into two groups.
Empowering beliefs help us make decisions, try new things and back ourselves. "I can work this out." "I learn quickly." "My experience counts for something."
Limiting beliefs do the opposite. They drain our energy and stop us from changing or trying something new. "I'm not enough." "It's too late for me." "I'll be found out."
The tricky thing about limiting beliefs is that they rarely feel like beliefs. They feel like the truth. And because they feel true, they become true. If I believe I can't draw, I won't try, I won't practise, and sure enough, I can't draw.
It's also worth knowing that the same belief can be empowering in one season of life and limiting in another. "I have to work harder than everyone else" might be exactly what got you your first leadership role. Twenty years on, it may be the very thing keeping you exhausted.
Four places limiting beliefs hide
In my work, I find limiting beliefs tend to show up in four ways:
Mistaken Identity: what I believe about who I am. "I'm not enough." "I have to prove myself."
Mistaken Meaning: what I believe a situation means. "I made a mistake, so I'm failing."
Mistaken Rules: the invisible rules I live by. "I should cope." "Good women don't disappoint people."
Mistaken Lens: how I interpret what's going on. "This is the only way to see this."
You don't need to memorise these. They're just a handy way to notice where a belief might be running the show.
The good news
Beliefs can change. They were learned, so they can be looked at again. Sometimes simply asking where a belief came from is enough to see that it was never really yours. Sometimes a little new evidence is all it takes. And sometimes it needs more practice, because the brain likes what's familiar. (I've written more about why that is here).
Either way, it starts with noticing.
This week's experiment
Catch one "I'm just…" or "I always…" you say about yourself this week. Then ask:
"Where did I learn that?"
And then ask yourself:
"Is it true, or is it just familiar?"
You may find the door you thought was a wall was only ever a belief.