What if you're not stuck, just on repeat?
Do you remember playing with plasticine or pipe cleaners as a kid? You could bend them into almost any shape you liked. A dog. A crown. A slightly wonky giraffe.
I sometimes wonder what it would be like if we could be that bendy in how we respond to people and situations. Not floppy. Just able to take whatever shape the moment actually needs.
That, in a nutshell, is behavioural flexibility.
Same situation, different response
Most of us have a few go-to responses we fall back on without thinking.
The colleague who pushes back, and we get defensive. The meeting where we're spoken over, and we go quiet. The piece of work we delegated, and we quietly take back. The family member who says that thing, and we bite. Every time.
These patterns aren't wrong. At some point they probably served us well. But if we keep getting the same unhelpful result, it might be time to try something different.
There's an old saying that insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. I'd put it more gently. It's not insanity. It's habit. And habits can change.
What is behavioural flexibility?
Behavioural flexibility is the ability to vary our own behaviour to get a different response, rather than falling back on the same habitual (and often limiting) reaction.
It means having a range of ways to respond to any situation, not just one.
And here's the bit I love. We can't control how other people behave. But we can change how we show up, and that often changes everything around us.
The committee member I didn't like
Many years ago I chaired a committee with a member I'll call Bob. As far as I could see, Bob didn't value anyone else's opinion and went out of his way to be difficult. Most of the committee felt the same. Our meetings got harder and harder, and we achieved very little.
I'd been learning about behavioural flexibility, so I decided to try it out on Bob.
Up until then, I'd angled my body away from him, kept eye contact to a minimum and enforced strict time limits on each agenda item, mostly to limit how much he could say. (Subtle, I know.)
So I changed what I was doing. I faced him directly. I made eye contact. I listened properly, and let him know I was trying to understand what he meant. I asked him open questions instead of rushing on to the next item.
Over the next few weeks and months, Bob's behaviour began to change. Then other committee members started to change too. We ended up achieving some great things together.
Do I like Bob now? Honestly, no. But we found a way to work together well. And the change didn't start with Bob, it started with me.
Why we get stuck on repeat
If flexibility is so useful, why don't we do it more?
Partly because our usual responses feel safe. They're familiar, and the brain loves familiar because it's easy to predict. (More on that here)
And partly because of what we believe. If I believe "Bob is impossible", I'll only ever see one way to deal with Bob. That's why behavioural flexibility and perspective shifting go hand in hand. A new perspective gives us choice, choice gives us flexibility, and flexibility is where our impact comes from. (More on perspective shifting here).
I once decided a puzzle I'd shared with my team couldn't be solved because the instructions looked incomplete. I promptly forgot about it. A team member emailed me the answer. Later I gave it to my teenage children, who solved it in ten minutes, in their heads. Sheesh. Once I'd decided it was impossible, I'd stopped looking for other ways in.
What behavioural flexibility isn't
This matters, especially for those of us who've spent years keeping everyone else happy.
Behavioural flexibility isn't bending yourself into whatever shape other people want. It isn't dropping your values, swallowing your opinion or always being the one who smooths things over.
In fact, for some of us, the flexible response is the one we haven't been using. Speaking up instead of going quiet. Saying no instead of yes. Leaving the work with the person we delegated it to.
Flexibility means you get to choose your response, rather than your habit choosing it for you.
This week's experiment
Tonight, before you go to sleep, think back over your day. Pick one moment that didn't go the way you'd have liked.
Then imagine three different ways you could have responded. They don't have to be perfect. They just have to be different.
Do this for a week and you'll notice something. When a similar moment comes along, you'll have more than one option ready to go.
And sometimes all it takes is one different response to open a door that's been stuck for years.
Maree